Members Area Logout

Members Movements: Oct 2023

New Members

Correspondent

  • David Pierson, Correspondent, The New York Times
  • Michael Mainville, Regional Director – Asia Pacific, Agence France-Presse
  • Mayumi Melissa Maruyama, Cable News Network International
  • Alexander Lynn, Hong Kong Bureau Chief, Pei Media
  • Josh Ye, China Technology Correspondent, Thomson Reuters

Associates

  • Linda Jane Connell , Solicitor
  • Hyuk Joon John Kwon, General Counsel Global Legal & Strategy, CATL
  • Kuresh Mohammed Bhai Sarjan, Managing Director, HSBC
  • Wai Yip Hin, Senior Partner, Henry Wai & Co
  • Duke Elmo Bonnin Malan, Director of Media, AIA Group
  • Choy Chak Kwan Eric, Equity Research Director, Citigroup Global Markets Asia
  • Graham Charles Lannoy, COO, BlackRock
  • Yiu Tat Suen, Director of IT, ACP Medication Management Centre
  • David Gregory Adams, Managing Director, AIn’t Games
  • Ho Stephen Wing Yuen
  • Cheung Queenie Lissa, Lawyer, Ashurst
  • Chan Nap Kee Joseph, Founding Partner, Oriental Patron Financial Group
  • Falaq Kagda, Freelance Editor and Writing Coach
  • Raul Fabian Lischka, Credit Suisse
  • Manohar Thakurdas Chugh, Chairman, Nisha Electronic Industries
  • Lam Joseph Chok, Director, Chok Station
  • Mildred Hugh Janelle, Retired
  • Chen Jia Feng, VP/Director, Metro Asia Investment Management
  • David Harley, Marine Insurance UK P & i Club/Thomas Miller
  • Richard Leong, The Hong Kong Jockey Club
  • Qi Jianan, Technical Director, Albamen Capital Partners
  • John Alexander McLean, General Counsel, Vistra Group
  • Gregg Li, Orion Astropreneur Space Academy
  • Ooi Gaik Cheng, Medical Doctor (Radiologist), Self Employed
  • Chung Wing Sze, Barrister-at-law
  • Elizabeth Furniss, Head of People Division Asia & Middle East, St James’s Place
  • Ng Sung Kei Michael, Managing Director of Finance Metropolitan Capital

Membership Replacements

Corporate

  • Vincenzo Crapanzano, Head of Financial Crime Prevention Audit, UBS AG
  • Wu Brian Danny, Managing Director, JP Morgan Chase Bank
  • Christopher Peter Woodward, Head of Family Office, Advisory, Asia Pacific, HSBC

Diplomatic

  • Venkata Ramana Kuchibatla, Consul General, Consulate General of India
  • Peter John Lund, Consul General, New Zealand Consulate-General

Absent

Correspondents

  • Robert James Fenner, Editor, Bloomberg News
  • Rebecca Anne Bailey, Correspondent, Agence France-Presse

Journalist

  • Andrea Zavadszky, Managing Editor, Lexipro Media Services

Associates

  • Peter Barrett, Retired
  • John McCormick, Consultant, Cathay Pacific Airways
  • Marguerite Anne Walker, Self-Employed
  • Simon James Pritchard, Global Research Director, Gavekal Research
  • Elizabeth Anne Wilson, Managing Director, Lynchpin Bondholder Management
  • Wijnandus Adrianus van Hoeven, Self-Employed
  • Yasmin Mahboobani, Managing Director, Jovian Creations
  • Howard Nathan Wheeler, Owner, LSR Services
  • James Jia-Chang Louie, Blu Inc Media
  • Scott Harrison, Managing Director, Aquis Search
  • Harmina Hilga Warringa, Owner, Summer & Co
  • Pekka Elias Antero Heikari, CEO, Eurasia Supply Chain Management
  • Murlidhar Maiya, Managing Director, JP Morgan Securities (Asia Pacific)
  • Nicholas John Thompson, Director, C & C Consulting
  • Hendrik Penndorf, Managing Director, YGM Trading
  • Richard Charles Allen Granger, Self-Employed
  • Au Wai Keung Stephen, Executive Director, Julius Baer & Co
  • Olivia Emily Emma Scott, Doctor, Townsville Hospital Health Services
  • Pang Kai Tao, Adjutant, Administration Group, Hong Kong Air Cadet Corps
  • Mounir Guen, CEO, MVision Private Equity Advisers Asia
  • Chan Pui Nga, Director, Bank of Nova Scotia
  • Dominic Alexander Rigby, CFO, Mvision
  • Ambar Taneja, CIO, Geomatrix (HK)
  • Kashyap Krishan Vazirani, Senior Trader, Macsteel International Far East
  • Wong Suk Yin, Chief Marketing Officer, Invest Hong Kong
  • Li Chun Hin Justin, Self-Employed
  • Tse Sharie Ross, Total Media
  • Li Quentin Chun Yin, Private Wealth Management, Goldman Sachs (Asia)
  • Wan Sim, Retired
  • Wu William Wai Leung, Self-Employed

 Reactivated

Correspondent

  • Nury Vittachi, Columnist
  • Anthony Spaeth, Editor, Korea Joong Ang Daily

Associates

  • Fok Kwong Hang Terry, Managing Director, T & F Equities
  • Julian Michael Stargardt, Director
  • Brett Anthony Rohrsheim, Self-Employed
  • Chan Kylie Candy Kei Kei, Associate Director, The Wall Street Journal
  • Elaine Davis, Chief Operating Officer, Nine Masts Capital
  • Gavin John Herrmann, Managing Director, Standard Chartered

Resigned

Journalist

  • Nicola Karen Burridge, Freelance
  • Chi Pan Year Ernest, General Manager, Sing Tao News
  • Fung Wai Kong, Consulting Editor, Hong Kong Economic Journal

Associates

  • Shanti Govindaraju, Senior Manager, PricewaterhouseCoopers
  • Anthony Langridge, Chairman, OneGlobal
  • Daniel Curry Chinoy, Self-Employed
  • Natalie Ann Williams, Vice President, Bank of New York Mellon
  • Tsui Yuk Siang Mabel, Barrister-at-Law, Victoria Chambers
  • Kishor Mistry, CEO, Peak Pacific
  • Mark Stephen Steed, Principal, CEO, Kellett School

Category Changes

  • Terry Duckham, Director, Asiapix Studios: Correspondent to Silver Correspondent
  • Wai Fun Angelina Hathey Cheung, Director, Hathey Int’l Holdings: Honorary Widow

Members Movements: July 2023

New Members

Correspondent

  • Lau Lauren Faith, Journalist, Bloomberg
  • Orla Elizabeth Ryan, Deputy Asia News Editor, Financial Times
  • James Wilson, Asia News Editor, Financial Times

Journalist

  • Kieran Cash, Production Editor, South China Morning Post
  • Becky Lee, Executive Producer, Freebase Media (HK)
  • Elisabet Maria Erika Helande, Editor in Chief, Bulletin
  • Lok Ho Yin Evelyn, Freelance Writer
  • Luk Chun Kau, Senior Managing Editor, Ming Pao Newspapers
  • Zheng Wei William, Senior China Correspondent, South China Morning Post

Associates

  • Edward Alexander Gordon Alder, Barrister at Law
  • Nicholas John Appel, Self-owned, Sourcing Solutions Far East
  • David Benskin, Co-Founder, 28 Advisory
  • John Binks, Strategy Director, Central Venue Management
  • Lawrence Brader, Investment funds & ETFs specialist, HSBC Hong Kong
  • John Charles Bugg, Self Employed / Investor
  • Mark Carr, Managing Director and Chief Enterprise Architect, Hong Kong Exchanges and Clearing
  • Nicholas Case, Founder & Chief Operations Officer, Armstrong-Hilton Communication
  • Chan Ka Shun Raymond, Food Business Director, Advance Caterers
  • Chan Wing Ping, Assistant General Manager, Takungpao Newspaper
  • Alexandre Huguet
  • Amos Chan, Associate Manager, Bank Julius Baer
  • Janssen Chan, Tax Professional (CPA), Anssen Consulting
  • Meryl Reine Chantilly, Managing Director, Ryuvision Holdings
  • Chen Peter Guang, China Partner, Deloitte
  • Cheng Kai Wah, Consultant, JTC Solicitors
  • Gautam Chellaram, CEO, KC Maritime Hong Kong
  • Veronica Chow, Lawyer, Howse Williams
  • Gerald Clough, Consultant, Catalyst International
  • Rianna Manoj Chugani, Account Director, Forrester Hong Kong
  • Chung Kaiwan, Pilot (Management), Greater Bay Airlines
  • Angus Roderick James Davidson, Fund Manager, Natixis Investment Managers
  • Michael Edward Sean Denmark, Chairman, Great Entertainment Group
  • Nicholas Drapac, Chief Executive Officer, Goldstrom
  • Tsoi Wai Kwan Michele Emmanuelle, Retired
  • Ho Chun Ki Frederick, Partner, Ho Tse Wai & Partners
  • Natalie Lee Fung, Consultant, PrincewaterhouseCoopers
  • Lee Ka Hok George, Partner, Guantao & Chow Solicitors and Notaries
  • Matthew Alexander Grange, Senior Communication Manager, HSBC
  • Michael Jeremy Griffiths, Retired
  • Richard Goss, Lecturer, The Chinese University of Hong Kong
  • Kazutora Hayashida, Seiga Asset Management
  • Roberta Hamilton
  • Michael Hieb, Chief Risk Officer, Segantii Capital Management
  • Paul Robert Hill, Investment Director, Ship Street Advisors
  • James Hill, Managing Partner, SEC Newgate Greater China
  • Trevor John Inglis, Procurement Executive, HSBC
  • Christopher John Purdon, Chief Investment Officer, Ship Street Advisors
  • Mukesh Kalra, Director, Mercury Global
  • Vibha Karnik, Partnership Manager, The Zubin Foundation
  • Lo Nga Lam Anna, Self-Employed
  • Wendy Leadbeater, Medical Support + Vet Nurse Education Manager, Mars Veterinary Health
  • Marcus Lee, Executive Officer, Government of the Hong Kong SAR
  • Vincent Gar-Gene Leung, CFO, AOP Capital
  • Tuomas Lilleberg, Entrepreneur, TMVL Consulting
  • John Lovell, Director, Diemens Pty
  • Sandeep Singh Mand, Finance Manager, Wolver Hill Asset Management Asia
  • Springer Maximilian, Managing Director, Salire Trading Company
  • Minal Ramesh Mahtani, CEO & Founder, OCD and Anxiety Support Hong Kong
  • Lee Shu Nung
  • Eileen O’Connell, Partner / Business Development, Ernst & Young (Hong Kong)
  • Russell Parker, Managing Director, Crater Gold Mining
  • Keng Guan Catherine Por, Solicitor, Messrs Stevens
  • Hitesh Chandiram Ratnani, Manager, C. Doulatram & Sons
  • Michael Rogers, Managing Director, Overland Trade
  • Peter Joseph Ryan-Kane, Investment Advisor, Perk Advisory
  • Nichlas Rydin, Vice President of Sales, Norebo Hong Kong
  • Tiger Shi, Chief Executive Officer, BANDS Financial
  • Clare Jane Marian Skinner, Operations Executive, Carey Olsen
  • George Gee Foo So, Retired
  • Benedict Sutton, Co-Founder and Executive Director, 28 Advisory
  • Joey Sung, Senior Director, Restructuring & Insolvency and Head of Forensic Services Perun Consultants
  • James Stewart, Managing Director, Goldman Sacks
  • Sze Lee Wah George, Managing Director, Systems Integrators <Asia>
  • Tai Choi Pan, Shipbroker, Clarksons Hong Kong
  • Tsang Wai Kit
  • Matthew Glynne Thomas, English Specialist, Consulate General of Japan
  • Ronald Brien Thompson, Managing Director, Alvarez & Marsal Corporate Finance
  • Anthony Williams, Consultant, Korn Ferry
  • Lo Po Wing, Barrister
  • Ceicy Wong, Managing Director, Vegware
  • Wong Cheuk Fung, Senior Executive Director Head of Sales (HK & SEA), CSOP Asset Management
  • Wong Hoi, Executive Director, First Distributor for films
  • Wong Kin Leung James, Partner, KPMG
  • Wong Tat Lun George, Director, Gtech Services (Hong Kong)
  • Woo Chiu Shui Dominic, Self-employed
  • Candice Yip, Head of HR International, Point 72
  • Young Cho Yee David, Director, Kingsway International Holdings
  • Mok Sin Yung, Senior Legal Manager, Ogier
  • Rumen Yordanov, Founder & Managing Director, Asian European Engineering

Membership Replacements

Corporate

  • Chan Tak Kin Kent, Technical Sales Manager, Gulf Oil Marine
  • Mark James Phin, Head of Investor Relations, Asia- Pacific, HSBC
  • Li Wah, General Manager, Corporate Affairs, Hong Kong Tourism Board
  • Loke Kevin Weng Yew, Executive Director, UBS AG

Diplomatic

  • Merks Lucille, Deputy Consul General, Consul General of the Kingdom of the Netherlands
  • David Lyons Stanford JR, Diplomat, Consulate General of the United States of America Christopher
  • Peter Woodward, Diplomat, British Consulate General Hong Kong

Absent

Correspondents

  • Enda Curran, Asia Finance Reporter, Bloomberg News
  • Linda Victoria Jenkins, Freelance Journalist
  • Anette Jonsson, Deputy Website Editor/Senior Equities Editor, FinanceAsia
  • Liu Heung Shing, Photographer, Shanghai Center of Photography

Journalist

  • Rachel Autherson, Freelance Journalist
  • Hui Kwan Yu, Jessie, Freelance
  • Christopher George Lincoln, Broadcaster
  • Elizabeth Lai Shar Lui-Belshaw, Freelance

Associates

  • Andrew A. Bruce, Barrister, QED Chambers
  • Angelo Catalano, Responsible Officer, Zhong Shan Asset Management
  • Eric Charrington, Retired
  • John Corbett, Psychologist / Lawyer
  • Christopher J. Dillon, Principal, Dillon Communications
  • Chen Hongyi, Senior Adviser, Hong Kong Institute for Monetary and Financial Research
  • Tan Shen Guan, Regional Executive Creative Director, Young & Rubicam
  • Karl M. Hurst, Owner, HT Capital Management
  • Michel Jospe, Managing Director, Methong Plastics (H.K.)
  • Lam Chun Yu Cadence, Director of Foster and Adoption Ministry, Solomon’s Porch
  • Law Pik Lin, Jessica, Vantage Asia Publishing
  • Leung Ho Ming, Founder & CEO, VICO Capital
  • Leung Ka Man, Portfolio Manager, Bluepool Capital
  • Li Jeremy Yuen Lim, Solicitor, Joseph C.T.Lee & Co. Solicitors
  • Wendy Evelyn McTavish, Managing Director, Expat Services
  • Gregory Pearce, Managing Director, One Space
  • Chan Pak Lin, Perry, Barrister-at-law, Olympia Chambers
  • Richard Stokes, Systems Advisor, Asia, CNN
  • Virginia Davis Wilmerding, Partner, Finsbury Glover Hering
  • Wong Ing Kwong, Douglas, Editor, Bloomberg Intelligence

 Reactivated

Correspondent

  • Bill Condon, Contributor – Comment HK, China Daily Hong Kong

Journalist

  • Brittyn Kim Clennett, Foreign Correspondent, ABC News

Associates

  • Anthony Robert Dick, Retired
  • Carolyn Sue Barwick, Retired
  • David Paul Grodentz, Group Systems Interface Lead, HSBC
  • Dagmar Claudia Jurick, Director, Pentland
  • Marguerite Anne Walker

Resigned

Correspondents

  • Chad David Williams, Senior Editor, Agence France Press

Journalist

  • Lucy Rebecca Rose Jenkins, Wine and Spirits Director, Tasting Kitchen

Associates

  • Dauwood Khan Malik, Managing Partner, Clifford Chance
  • Giuseppe Milito, Managing Partner, China & Singapore / Executive Coach, Clifford Chance
  • Wong Lena Sing Ying, General Manager, Fossil

Category Changes

Journalist to Correspondent

  • Karlene Rebeca H. Cox, Regional Managing Editor, Tatler Asia
  • Danai Carolyn Howard, Newsdesk Editor, Agence France-Presse

Correspondent  to Silver-Correspondent

  • Tan Lee Hock, Publisher & Founder, Asia Asset Management

Deaths

We regret to announce the deaths of:

  • Bhagoo Hathey, Director, Hathey Int’l Holdings

Honorary Widow

  • Lance Montague Burbidge, Chief Investor Relations Officer, AIA
  • Lucy Burger, Research Fellow

Members Movements: April 2023

New Members

Correspondent

  • Vicky Feng, Video Producer, Bloomberg
  • Robin Harding, Editor Correspondent, The Financial Times (Hong Kong) Limited Asia
  • Paul Tait, Senior Editor Correspondent, Agence France-Presse

Journalist

  • Lucy Jenkins, Wine and Spirits Director, Tasting Kitchen
  • Caleb Loong, Principal Reporter / Sub-editor, Now TV

Associates

  • Marc Baloch, CEO, Resonance Asia
  • Michael Bugel, Managing Director, Co-Head of APAC, Alternative Investment Management Association
  • Wenwen Chai, Senior Associate, Karas LLP
  • Paul Christopher, Managing Partner, Mourant Ozannes (Hong Kong) LLP
  • Timothy Davis, Senior Director of Security, Prudential
  • Charles Donohoe, Director, BlackRock
  • Francis Law, Executive Director, Toyo Mall Limited
  • Michael Lin, US Patent Attorney and Ohio Attorney, Marks & Clerk
  • Neville Metcalfe, Regional IT Director of Asia, Mayer Brown
  • Gareth Shaw, Captain, Jet Aviation Hong Kong
  • Minny Siu, Partner, King & Wood Mallesons
  • Syed Pervez Hussain, Chairman and Founder, Syed Group of Companies
  • Peter Szekely, Managing Partner, Tanarra Credit Partners
  • Angie Tse, Head of Development, Hong Kong Maritime Museum
  • Marco Warmelink, Partner, Actuarial Leader, APR, Oliver Wyman
  • David Watt, Senior Advisor, BentallGreenOak
  • Pierre Widmer, Managing Director, Market Team Head SEA, Global Wealth
  • Shirley Wong, Retired
  • Li Xiaobing, President of South China & Hong Kong, ZIM Integrated Shipping Services Ltd.
  • Robert Yang, Retired
  • Gary Yin, Partner, Simmons & Simmons

Diplomatic

  • Henry Chan, Honorary Consul, Honorary Consulate of the Republic of Namibia
  • Colin Crosby, Deputy Consul General, US Consulate General
  • Roxie Houge, Diplomat, US Consulate General
  • Klára Jurčová, Consul General, Consulate General of the Czech Republic
  • Lam Kwok Hing, Honorary Consul, Honorary Consulate of the Republic of Senegal
  • Matthew Lam, Honorary Consul, Honorary Consulate of the Republic of Estonia
  • Gregory May, Counsel General, US Consulate General
  • Raj Sitaldas Motwani, Honorary Consul, Honorary Consulate of the Republic of Lithuania

Absent

Correspondents

  • James Chambers, Bureau Chief, Monocle
  • Chiang Susie Su-Hui, Chairman, CS Culture Foundation
  • Zachary Coleman, Opinion Editor, Nikkei Asia
  • Chen Hangyu, Video Producer, Time Magazine
  • Mary Kavanagh, Freelance Journalist and Editor
  • Joyce Lau, Breaking News Editor, Washington Post
  • Mitya New, Director, Leading Organisations
  • Richard Newell, Managing Editor, IPE International Publishers

Journalist

  • Edward Chin Chi Kin, Freelance Journalist and Commentator, HKEJ
  • Rachel Duffell, Freelancer Editor
  • Daniel Kadison, Founder, NewsWhistle
  • Tang Yuk Shan, Business News Editor, Hong Kong Economic Journal
  • Yuen Kin Kwok, Freelancer

Associates

  • Brandon Chau, Barrister-at-law, Cheng Huan SC Chambers
  • Johnny Cheng, Retired
  • Maxwell Cooke, Chief Executive Officer, Lauren Richards
  • Anthony Dick, Director, Tea Concepts
  • Simon Dodd, Director, ABN AMRO Bank
  • Adam Enright, Senior Captain, Cathay Pacific Airways
  • Michael Fagan, General Counsel, PCCW
  • Terry Fok, Managing Director, T & F Equities
  • Robert Grieves, Chairman, Hamilton Advisors
  • Vanessa Hemavathi, Head of Investment Services, Privium Fund Management
  • Mary Ho, Adjunct Assistant Professor, Hong Kong University of Science and Technology
  • Jon Zinke Keesal, Resident Partner, Young & Logan
  • Li Yan Lin, Physician, Queen Mary Hospital
  • Christopher Morley, Partner, Morley Chow Seto
  • Shirley Ng, Self-Employed
  • Andrew Paterson, Regional Head, Asia Pacific, ADEC Innovations
  • Jenny Pu, Consultant of Neurosurgery, Queen Mary Hospital
  • Gustav Ronnholm, Director, Finn-Flare
  • Vikram Singh, Managing Director, Air Logistics
  • Jonathan Sparks, Managing Director, Emerge 360
  • Su-Mei Thompson, Chief Executive Officer, Media Trust
  • Michael Tomordy, Technology & Risk Advisory, Engage Asia
  • Polly Yu, Director, Polly Yu Production

 Reactivated

Correspondent

  • Gavin Greenwood, Freelance
  • Linda Jenkins, Freelance Writer

Associates

  • Eric Charrington, Retired
  • John Cook, Director, Consulting On Q
  • Pekka Heikari, Chief Executive Officer, Eurasia Supply Chain Management
  • Stephen Hire, Vice President of Marketing, Viavi Solutions
  • David Hodson, Hon. Fellow, The University of Hong Kong
  • Goran Kostic, Product Management, Swift SCRL Head of Integration
  • Philip Krichilsky, Chief Executive Officer, Innovative Directions
  • Jessica Law Pik Lin, Self-Employed
  • Ng Man Fong, Director, Another Factory
  • Michael Pitcher, Retired

Resigned

Correspondents

  • Jonathan Breen, Equities Editor, Global Capital Asia, Euromoney Institutional Investor
  • Roger Clark, Vice President & Bureau Chief, CNN
  • Philippe Massonnet, Regional Director, Agence France-Presse

Associates

  • Gabrielle Churchouse, Director, Portwood
  • Frank Proctor, Pacific Edition General Manager, Newsweek
  • Wong Yu Hon Johan, Managing Director, Wepro180

Corporate

  • Ella Lee Wai Man, Director, The University of Hong Kong
  • Leong Ka Chai, Director, Roctec Credit
  • Max Shen Zuojun, Vice-President & Pro-Vice-Chancellor (Research), The University of Hong Kong

Diplomatic

  • Warren Ke, Diplomat, US Consulate General

Members Movements: January 2023

New Members

Journalist

  • Danai Howard, Digital Production Editor, South China Morning Post
  • Jarrod Watt, Specialist Digital Editor, South China Morning Post
  • Laura Westbrook, Correspondent, South China Morning Post

Associates

  • Geoffrey Blowers, Professor (Faculty of Social Sciences), UOW College Hong Kong
  • Chiang Hsin, Executive Director, Goldman Sachs (Asia)
  • Chiu Yeung, Executive Director, L&D Consultants Incorporation
  • David Chou Tse Young, Self-Employed
  • Derryl D’Silva, Head of Resource Management, Bank for International Settlements
  • Ernest Dodoo, Neurosurgeon, Hospital Authority
  • Simon Goddard, Global Deputy Head of Investigation, Prudential PLC
  • Sean Hung, Golf Professional, Pacific Pine Sports
  • Nichola Irwin, Doctor, Optimal Family Health
  • Vincent Li, Valuer, Colliers
  • Liu Ho Yuen, Senior Manager, Pricewaterhouse Cooper
  • Howard Liu, Risk Consulting Associate, The Risk Advisory Group
  • Martin Lo, Associate, Vivien Chan & Co
  • Jonathan Macey, hairman & Founder, Macey & Sons Auctioneers and Valuers
  • Thomas Macey, Partner, Cask Master
  • Fernando Rys, Director, Innoin
  • Nicholas Tam, Legal Manager, Ogier
  • Aldrich Victorino, Business Development Director, Dynasty Enterprise (Asia)

Diplomatic

  • Clay Adler, Diplomat, Consulate General of the United States of America
  • David Lie, HM Honorary Consul, The Honorary Consul of The Hashemite Kingdom of Jordan
  • Laurence Vandewalle, Deputy Head, European Union Office to Hong Kong and Macao

Membership Replacements

Diplomatic

  • Sapphire Le Sage, Consul (Political & Communications), British Consulate General
  • Alastair Stewart McEachern, Diplomat, Australian Consulate-General Hong Kong
  • Christine Elizabeth Meyer, Diplomat, Consulate General of the United States of America
  • Timo Kantola, Consul General, Consulate General of Finland
  • Zhang Tao, Bank for International Settlements, Chief representative

Absent

Correspondents

  • Matthew Brooker, Columnist, Bloomberg
  • Elizabeth Anne Lucy Colback, Freelance
  • Jennifer Huang, Freelance
  • Jennifer Hughes, Asia Columnist, Thomson Reuters
  • Huh Dong Hyuck, Reporter, New Daily Korea
  • Tripti Lahiri, Asia Bureau Chief, Quartz Atlantic Media
  • Joseph Leahy, Asian News Editor, Financial Times
  • Natalie Koh Sui Li, Acting Managing Editor, Haymarket
  • Emiri Yamamoto, Head of Asia TV, Bloomberg

Journalist

  • Andrew Shuen Pak Man, Presenter, YouTube SPM Channel
  • Wong Yee Wai, Freelance

Associates

  • Carolyn Barwick, Retired
  • Daniel Chinoy, Self-employed
  • Ellen Coetzee, Wine Manager, Dairy Farm Company
  • Neil Donovan, Head of Department, Singapore International School
  • Jonathan Garner, Managing Director, Morgan Stanley Asia
  • Vijay Kumar Valiram Harjani, Retired
  • Ashley Howlett, General Counsel and Legal Director, Gammon Construction
  • Catherine Morris, Client Partner/Program Manager, Menrva Group
  • Ivy Ng Wing Yee, Director, DAKA Fine Wines
  • Leon Price, Chairman, Dragon Racing International
  • Jacinta Reddan, Chief Executive, Australian Chamber of Commerce
  • Kaushik Roy, SHEQ Manager, Mitsui OSK Lines
  • Divya Sahney, Founder, Hi Didi
  • Mona Shroff, Director, Mona Shroff Jewellery
  • William Stork, Contributing Editor, Yale International Alliance
  • Tsang Meiling, Economics Teacher and IA Coordinator, Dulwich International High School Suzhou John B Wilson, Director (Technical), SCB Management Consulting Services
  • Bruce Yung Pak Keung, Self-employed

 Reactivated

Correspondent

  • Michael Duckworth, Publisher, Hong Kong University Press

Journalist

  • Enid Tsui, Arts Editor, South China Morning Post
  • Owen Fung Heung Wang, Reporter, TVB Pearl
  • Mark Graham, Proprietor, Mark Graham Associates

Associates

  • David Cain, Executive Managing Director, Brookfield Global Integrated Solutions
  • Maxwell Cooke, CEO, Lauren Richards HK
  • Philip Eisenbeiss, Partner, Executive Access
  • Antony E Keenan, Retired
  • Justin Li Chun Hin, Self-employed
  • Christopher Morley, Partner, Morley Chow Seto
  • Nigel Raymont, Coaching & Training Consultant, N Consulting
  • Brett Rohrsheim, Self-employed
  • Shalean Sen, Director, Mobius Advice
  • Michael Tomordy, Managing Director, Engage Asia
  • Alexander Williams, Chairman, Wogen Pacific

Resigned

Correspondents

  • Raymond Barrett, Editor-in-Chief Insurance, Asia News
  • Ryan Brooks, Senior Producer, Thomson Reuters
  • Richard Dowell, Asia Editor, Wall Street Journal
  • Paul Geitner, Editor, Bloomberg
  • Ravi Mattu, Deputy Asia News Editor, Financial Times
  • Filipe De Souza Azambuja Pacheco, Reporter, Bloomberg
  • Catherine Rice, TV News Journalist, Worldwide TV News
  • Matthieu Jean Joseph Verrier, Journalist, Urban Utopia (France)
  • Thomas Walker, Freelance

Associates

  • Alberto Aliverti, Director, Sailetto China
  • Colin Bennett, Managing Director, Kaplink
  • John Berry, Business Development Director, Asia Plantation Capital
  • Audrey Campbell-Moffat, Judge, Court of First Instance
  • Jay Chen, Director, Golden Holdings
  • Catherine Cheung Ka Yin, Chief Operating Officer, Tybourne Capital Management
  • Peter Goulston, Vice President, Fox-Pitt Kelton
  • Charles Scheyd, CEO, FJS Consultants

Category Changes

Associate to Silver Associate 

  • Connie Leung Bolland, Chief Economist, Economic Research Analysis

Correspondent to Associate

  • Michael Duckworth, Publisher, Hong Kong University Press

A Deep Downward Spiral: The State of Press Freedom in Southeast Asia

Since Maria Ressa won the Nobel Peace Prize this autumn, press freedom in Asia has come under scrutiny. FCC Fellow Amy Sood surveys a fraught situation.

In October, Maria Ressa – one of the Philippines’ most famous journalists – and Dmitry Muratov from Russia jointly won the 2021 Nobel Peace Prize. Both have come under fire for “efforts to safeguard freedom of expression, which is a precondition for democracy and lasting peace,” wrote the The Norwegian Nobel Committee in its selection announcement.  

Ressa, the first Filipina Nobel laureate, is the co-founder and chief executive of Rappler news site. Since president Rodrigo Duterte took office in 2016, Ressa has faced at least 10 arrest warrants and seven court cases over the outlet’s coverage of Duterte’s lethal “war on drugs”. Despite her Nobel prize, Ressa continues to face an onslaught of legal cases ranging from tax evasion to defamation, and at the time of writing, is out on bail while appealing a six-year prison sentence for libel.  

“I don’t know where [the prize] will lead,” Ressa told the Associated Press. “But I know that if we keep doing our task, staying on mission, holding the line, that there’s a better chance that our democracy not only survives, but that I also stay out of jail. Because I’ve done nothing wrong except be a journalist. That is the price we have to pay.”  

For journalists and media observers, Ressa’s Nobel prize serves as a call to action in the face of increasing censorship, harassment and restrictions in Southeast Asia, where most countries languish in the bottom half of the World Press Freedom Index. 

According to Phil Robertson, deputy director of Human Rights Watch’s Asia Division, press freedom is on a “deep downward spiral” across the region. “Leaders across the board in Southeast Asia are attempting to marginalise the media in any way that they can,” he says. 

“These governments are not afraid to criminalise reporting they see as being against their policies and their priorities. It’s doing a massive disservice to the people of Southeast Asia, who deserve access to quality media with independent views that are prepared to speak truth rather than parrot the line of the various governments.” 

Phil Robertson Phil Robertson, deputy director of Human Rights Watch’s Asia Division.

‘We could still be killed’

In the Philippines, which ranks 138 out of 180 countries and territories in the World Press Freedom Index, Jonathan de Santos, chair of the National Union of Journalists of the Philippines (NUJP), laments the state of press freedom. 

“In terms of recognition, [Ressa’s Nobel prize] is good. It sends a message that the world is watching,” he says. “But in terms of actual attitude on the ground, I’m not sure how much it will change. Journalists are still under threat and we could still be killed.” 

Robertson agrees, pointing to the Duterte administration’s steady efforts to control the press and the internet. For instance, in May 2020, the government declined to renew the licence of the Philippines’ largest broadcast network, ABS-CBN, which often covered “the war on drugs”. A statement by the NUJP said this shutdown denied millions of people access to essential information during the pandemic and “proves how the tyrant fears truth-tellers.” 

At least 22 journalists have died since Duterte took power in June 2016 and he has declared he would like to “kill journalism” in the Philippines, referring to reporters as “spies”, “vultures” and “lowlifes”.    

On 9 December, Jesus “Jess” Malabanan – a journalist involved in the Pulitzer Prize-winning investigation by Reuters into Duterte’s “war on drugs” – became the 22nd Filipino journalist killed in recent years. He was shot in the head by unknown gunmen on the central island of Samar. 

De Santos says the dangers of reporting have led journalists to self-censor when writing about government affairs, in fear of cyber-attacks or of being “red-tagged” – labelled as communists or terrorists – often without evidence. “This is part of a trend in the region,” he says. “I’ve been talking to colleagues from Indonesia and Malaysia, and they’re facing similar situations so it’s hard for us to get courage from each other.” 

Jonathan de Santos Jonathan de Santos (left) chairs the Philippines’ Union of Journalists.

Indonesia, which sits at 113th on the Index, has also seen troubling patterns of media suppression, says Indonesian investigative journalist Febriana Firdaus. The reporter, who recently moved to Bali because she felt unsafe in Jakarta, covers sensitive topics, such as West Papuan independence and LGBTI+ discrimination. Firdaus fears violence against reporters and their family members.  

For Firdaus, a recent explosion at the home of the parents of Indonesian social justice lawyer Veronica Koman – who frequently speaks up about human rights abuses in West Papua – made the possibility of violence feel probable, if not inevitable. “That was a warning for me, that perhaps it’s no longer safe for me to stay in my country if I want to report on these issues,” says Firdaus.  

There’s good reason to worry. Mara Salem Harahap, the chief editor of a local news outlet in North Sumatra, was shot dead in June. His family said that they believe Harahap’s murder was related to his work, citing past incidents of harassment and violence linked to his reporting on organised crime and drug-dealers. 

Indonesia’s Alliance of Independent Journalists (AJI), an organisation defending press freedom, recorded 84 cases of violence against journalists in the country in 2020 – the highest number reported since the group started collecting data in 2006. Since 2018, AJI has ranked the police as the top perpetrators of violence against journalists. In 2020, the police accounted for 55 of the 84 cases, which led AJI to denounce law enforcement as the “enemy of press freedom”.  

As in the Philippines, the message seems to come from the top. According to Firdaus, President Joko Widodo’s government likens “good journalism” to the strategies employed by “public relations professionals”, and expects reporters to spin a positive image of the country or face consequences. These range from fines and online harassment to potential prison time or physical violence. 

Indonesia has also renewed attempts to suppress press freedom during the COVID-19 pandemic through legal means. In April 2020, the Indonesian National Police issued law-enforcement guidelines banning journalists from publishing false information related to the pandemic or deemed hostile to the government. Furthermore, the country has increasingly used another law, the Electronic Information and Transactions Law (UUITE), to threaten journalists with prosecution. Under the UUITE, journalists could face up to six years in prison if found guilty.  

In addition, the government has blocked journalists from transmitting information from remote regions during emergencies. For example, in August 2019, it shut down internet access amid violent protests in West Papua “to accelerate government efforts to restore order”. However, the move also effectively silenced journalists trying to share news during the crisis. 

Febriana Firdaus Journalist Febriana Firdaus covers social justice issues in Indonesia.

Clamp-down on independent media

Singapore, which ranks 160th on the Index, has deployed similar legal and regulatory tactics. The ruling People’s Action Party (PAP), introduced the Protection from Online Falsehoods and Manipulation Act and the broadly worded Foreign Interference Countermeasures Act in 2021.  

Robertson of Human Rights Watch says that PAP has deployed a “scorched earth’’ policy against independent media outlets like New Naratif and The Online Citizen with a goal to “wipe them out.” 

Historian Dr Thum Ping Tjin is the managing director of New Naratif, an independent current affairs website covering Southeast Asia. Thum, one of three Singaporeans who established the publication, says PAP implemented these laws to stifle critical or alternative voices. “It’s very important to recognise that the main way in which these laws suppress media freedom is not so much in the letter of the law, but in its ability to scare Singaporeans into self-censoring,” he says. As long as reporters live in fear of conducting journalism, there is no freedom of the press, he adds. 

Although current press freedom trends around the region indicate a clamp-down on independent media outlets, Thum believes some publications will endure because humans have historically resisted suppression and fought for the right to speak, write and live freely.   

For example, Malaysian independent news site Malaysiakini has persisted despite enduring hostility from the government in the form of police raids, criminal charges and prosecutions over the years. Earlier this year,  the Federal Court of Malaysia found the publication guilty of contempt over online comments from readers – claiming they undermined public confidence in the judiciary.  

However, multiple independent outlets across Asia have shut down despite initial resistance. Within a year of Hong Kong’s National Security Law coming into effect, authorities arrested Next Digital founder Jimmy Lai and other top executives, forcing Apple Daily to print its last edition in June 2021. Since then, Lai has been convicted of organising an illegal rally and inciting others to take part in an unlawful assembly. In December, authorities filed new charges of conspiracy to “print, publish, sell, offer for sale, distribute, display and/or reproduce seditious publications” against Lai and other former Next Digital executives.  

Dr Thum Ping Tjin Dr Thum Ping Tjin, managing director of independent news outlet New Naratif. (Photo: Thum Ping Tjin / New Naratif)

 

In Singapore, the government permanently cancelled the licence of local political blog The Online Citizen in October, because it refused to reveal its funding sources and “did not fully comply” with legal obligations.  

Robertson believes the region’s future will depend on whether countries around the world help fight for press freedom or just turn a blind eye. “The international community has to step in and also throw some elbows [push back] against these governments, demanding press freedom be upheld,” he urges.  

Despite the high-stakes atmosphere in Indonesia, Firdaus chooses to press on, saying she feels a responsibility to tell the stories of the people she meets in conflict zones. “The fear I feel is not greater than my moral responsibility to these people as a journalist,” she says. 

Ressa, who was unavailable for comment, has publicly vowed to carry on as well. In her Nobel Peace Prize acceptance speech in Oslo on 10 December, Ressa condemned authoritarian governments and social media giants for spreading misinformation and sowing discord. 

“[Technology] has allowed a virus of lies to infect each of us, pitting us against each other, bringing out our fears, anger, hate, and setting the stage for the rise of authoritarians and dictators around the world,” she said.  

Ressa also expressed concern about the upcoming elections in the Philippines, due to be held in May 2022. “I’ve said this repeatedly over the last five years: without facts, you can’t have truth. Without truth, you can’t have trust. Without trust, we have no shared reality, no democracy, and it becomes impossible to deal with the existential problems of our times: climate, coronavirus, now, the battle for truth. How can you have election integrity if you don’t have integrity of facts?”   

Though much remains uncertain, Ressa shared her vision for peace, trust and empathy. “Every day, I live with the real threat of spending the rest of my life in jail because I’m a journalist,” she said. “I have no idea what the future holds, but it’s worth the risk. The destruction has happened. Now it’s time to build – to create the world we want.”

Amy Sood is an FCC Clare Hollingworth fellow and a digital verification reporter at AFP in Hong Kong, monitoring misinformation in India and Indonesia. Prior to her current role, she was an intern at CNN and NBC News. 

How COVID-19 Has Impacted Hong Kong Media

As Rick Boost discovers, the pandemic has pushed many media organisations in Hong Kong to adjust workplace policies, find new revenue streams and come out stronger. 

When COVID-19 swept across the globe in early 2020, it pummeled many media companies. Some slashed freelance budgets, others cut staff, closed offices and reduced nonessential spending.

Here in Hong Kong, we’ve witnessed mass staff layoffs and office closures – as seen at i-Cable and Quartz, respectively – as well as radical shifts in how teams work together. Nearly two years on, media companies in Hong Kong have found some footing, but the ground continues to shift.

“In early 2020, no one could have foreseen the impact that COVID would have on our personal and professional lives and changed the ways we live, work and interact,” says Atifa Silk, the Asia managing director of Haymarket Media.

“We had to adapt quickly and, thankfully, most of our people were able to embrace the changes and reap the rewards that working from home can bring.”

Magazines Entertainment and media revenue in Hong Kong plummeted 11.8 percent, or US$1 billion, in 2019, according to PWC.

The great migration

In early 2020, the government appealed to employers to allow staff to work from home to minimise social contact. Many Hong Kong media companies, including Haymarket, swiftly instated mandatory work-from-home (WFH) policies and entered a period of trial-and-error.

While Haymarket identified many benefits with remote work – more efficient meetings, fewer distractions, no commutes, time with family – they encountered a fair share of hurdles, too. “The sparks of creativity that happen in face-to-face conversations are hard to replicate virtually,” says Silk. “There can be fewer opportunities for immediate support and training for young talent. And there is the pressure of feeling like you’re always on – that lack of separation between work and home life can impact wellbeing and mental health.”

In September 2020, Haymarket conducted a company-wide survey on flexible work, asking staff: “Would you value the option to work from home one to two days a week?” Roughly 96 percent of staff in Asia responded positively. So, in November 2020, the company began piloting a flexible work model that encouraged employees to work from home. Since moving into a new office in Sheung Wan in August 2021, the company has refined the model. Now, all staff work in the office three days a week – two of which centre around collaborative tasks.

Cliff Buddle, special projects editor at the South China Morning Post and FCC board member, says remote work shook up the legacy publication. “For the first time in our history, we produced a newspaper with no editorial staff in the newsroom,” he says. “This was done at very short notice when our office temporarily closed. It was an impressive achievement, given that print publication requires much collaboration.”

Nick Thorpe, the East Asia director of media intelligence platform Telum Media, says many media companies in Asia had resisted the move toward remote work before the pandemic due to a “complex web of cultural and social hurdles”.

“Some staff had never worked from home before and found the prospect so alien – both due to traditional workplace structures and small apartments,” he continues.

“Some [people] opted to remain office-based even at the height of the pandemic, while others have barely been into the office for 18 months.”

By contrast, some young, nimble companies like Liv Media have long preferred flexible work models, encouraging employees to work remotely since launching its flagship, Liv magazine, in 2015.

“While there is a slight tradeoff in efficiency, we have seen great staff retention and overall employee satisfaction as people feel they have more control over their lives,” says Sarah Fung, Liv Media’s founder and publisher. “Productivity isn’t measured by a punch card – if you have good employees, you can trust them to manage their own schedules.”

 


5 Media Trends to Watch

  1. Remote Work: WFH will become an acceptable, and expected, aspect of employment.
  2. Health and Safety: Wellbeing in all its many guises will be an essential part of any work contract.
  3. Audiophilia: Podcasts are commanding more and more attention.
  4. New Revenue Streams: With so much free content on offer, media must look to value-added services.
  5. Social Media+: Instagram, Facebook, Twitter and their progeny will command ever greater importance.
Sarah Fung During the downturn, Liv Media publisher Sarah Fung looked to new revenue streams such as awards, supplements and content creation.

Revising revenue streams

COVID-19 exposed the vulnerabilities of many industries – and media was not spared. In its “Global Entertainment and Media Outlook 2020-2024: Hong Kong Summary”, PricewaterhouseCoopers (PWC) reports that entertainment and media revenue in Hong Kong plummeted 11.8 percent, or US$1 billion, from US$8.5 billion in 2019 to US$7.8 billion in 2020.

“Hong Kong revenue was the worst-hit compared to global and Asia-Pacific markets,” states the report. The study also found that newspapers, magazines, and online advertising markets shrank, while video games, podcasts and over-the-top video services (such as Netflix or Hulu) grew.

“The pandemic has created a challenging environment for news organisations around the world,” Buddle adds. “The economic impact has hit advertising revenues, exacerbating problems newsrooms were already facing in finding new income streams and operating models. Those challenges will continue, although there are signs of improvement in Hong Kong as social-distancing restrictions are lifted.”

Organisations like Liv Media also felt the squeeze. “Lifestyle media budgets have been affected massively,” says Fung. “When the pandemic hit, our core sales categories – hospitality, travel and tourism, food, beverage and gyms – completely disappeared.”

During the downturn, Liv Media changed its strategy to look beyond traditional advertising. A significant portion of the brand’s revenue now comes from events, awards, guides, supplements, and bespoke content creation.

Fung also rolled out a free subscription service for readers and increased Liv magazine’s distribution network to 500 points across Hong Kong. These strategies – combined with the return of traditional ad spending – have put Liv in a stronger position for growth post-pandemic, she adds.

Haymarket also regrouped and pivoted. According to Silk, the company evaluated its operations, portfolio and services. For example, Haymarket conducted market research on the finance and marketing-communications industries, including qualitative interviews with readers and clients to better understand their needs.

The company also expanded its content solutions arm, leaned into subscription models and shifted its content strategy, adopting new tools, such as the digital storytelling platform Shorthand, to boost audience engagement.

“We challenged ourselves to think differently about our audiences and platforms,” says Silk. “The reset enabled us to reshape the Asia business and transform our revenue and financial profile, giving us a clear focus on building digital-first ideas and solutions.”

PWC’s more recent outlook, published in July, seems more optimistic. The report anticipates a 7.65 percent rise in Hong Kong’s 2021 entertainment and media revenues, from US$7.8 billion in 2020 to a projected US$8.4 billion in 2021.

Fung says she’s seen some renewed momentum on the sales front. “We’ve found that clients are starting to come back,” she says. “I think they’re tired of waiting for the pandemic to end and have realised that they need to keep marketing through the ‘new normal’.”

Many companies have leaned into digital-first storytelling.

Evolving career paths

Though the employment market for media professionals seemed dire this time last year, job openings in the industry seem to be picking up again. Thorpe says he’s observed exponential growth in the number of roles posted across Asia on Telum’s online Jobs Board.

“We’ve seen a lot of media outlets subsequently bounce back and kick-start hiring again, with digital and video journalism seeing a particular focus alongside more traditional reporting roles,” he says.

But now, publishers and editors prefer new hires to be just as diverse as their new revenue streams. “There’s probably not as much of a career path for someone who is just a writer post-COVID-19,” says Fung. “Employers are looking for media professionals with lots of strings in their bow, whether that’s graphic design, SEO, social media, photography or paid content creation.”

Thorpe broadly agrees, adding that the global crisis has shaken up traditional career paths in media. The pandemic – combined with a wealth of content creation channels online – has enabled many people with multimedia skills, like podcasting or video production, to break into the industry.

Thorpe expects that aspiring and existing media professionals alike will likely need to gain new skills in order to keep up. “There has been an explosion in media brands seeking experts in data, social media, video journalism, digital content creation and so on,” says Thorpe. “And of course, every media brand is looking at audio content today – there’s a gold rush in podcasting right now that shows no sign of slowing any time soon.”

 


Post-COVID Skill Set

Employers are increasingly seeking enhanced skills such as:

  • Video production
  • Audio production
  • Livestreaming
  • Graphic design
  • Social media skills
  • Writing for new media formats

 

Rick Boost is a born and raised Hongkonger. He has overseen copy and multimedia content at several of the city’s media outlets, including as HK Editor of Marketing Magazine/Interactive.

2021 Human Rights Press Awards Winners on Why Their Work Matters

It is lamentable that there was no shortage of entries for the 25th edition of the Human Rights Press Awards, which are organised by the FCC, Amnesty International and the Hong Kong Journalists Association. But as Rhea Mogul reports, the high standard of submissions was inspirational.

At the helm of any news story is a fierce commitment to telling the truth. Under increasing political and societal pressure, journalists now more than ever understand the need for urgent, accurate and nuanced reporting that holds power to account and defends vulnerable communities.

Despite increasing challenges, journalists’ unwavering quest for the truth remains one of the bulwarks of free expression and a free press. Their storytelling has exposed uncomfortable realities and given a voice to the voiceless.

Now in its 25th year, the Human Rights Press Awards sets out to celebrate the work of journalists from across Asia who have demonstrated tremendous courage in honouring these principles. Organised by the FCC, the Hong Kong Journalists Association (HKJA) and Amnesty International Hong Kong, this year’s winners were announced on 6 May.

Even in the face of particularly difficult times, which included a global pandemic and political upheaval, the winning journalists delivered original and compelling rights-related reporting that exposed wrongdoing.

The Correspondent spoke with a selection of winners about their work, what it reveals and why it matters.

 


 

Photography: Single Image
‘The Struggle’ by Alex Chan Tsz-yuk, CityDog.by

Freelance journalist Alex Chan Tsz-yuk’s winning photograph of a Hong Kong protester being held to the ground by two policemen was taken on 10 May 2020, after clashes broke out between the police and anti-government protesters in Mong Kok. Some 230 people were arrested that day, and the HKJA strongly condemned police treatment of reporters covering the event.

Alex Chan: “I saw three very young protesters get arrested. One young man – the one in the photograph – was trying to reach for something as the police arrested him, but he was pushed to the ground. His fingers then spread open to show the protest slogan ‘five demands, not one less’. That is why I named it ‘The Struggle’ because I think it matches what Hong Kong people are facing after the passing of the National Security Law. They continue with their struggle under political repression.

“That day was one of the most unfriendly journalists ever experienced at the hands of the Hong Kong police. Soon after I took the shot, I was pepper sprayed mercilessly. Some journalists, including myself, were forced to kneel down and stop recording. But instead of stopping, I took out a GoPro and continued my work.  

“The police also told us to show our press cards and made us say our names in front of a camera. They said they had recorded us for illegal assembly. During the very unpleasant experience, my only thought was that I need to protect the pictures I took, and try to publish it as soon as possible. As a journalist I will keep doing my work, document and tell the truth.”

 


 

Explanatory Feature Writing: Chinese
‘From Faceless to Voiceless: A Documentary Report of Hong Kong Citizens in Anti-Extradition Law Amendment Bill Movement and National Security Law’ by Hung-Chin Chen, Tzu-Lei Yang, Long-Hei Chan, Yu-Ju Lee, Tzy-Tyng Chen, Hanshun Wang, Ling-Wei Hsu, Yu-Fang Lin, Cheng-He Mi, Ya-Wun Jheng, Yi-Ching Wu, Yu-Chieh Chen, Yi-Fen Kao and Chun-Hsien Lee, Mirror Media

Journalists from the Taiwan-based publication Mirror Media spent one year documenting how the lives of Hong Kong protesters changed after the implementation of the National Security Law. The judges praised their probing interviews, which encapsulated the feelings of Hong Kong people.

Hung-Chin Chen, one of the winning journalists on the Mirror Media team, explains: “I visited Hong Kong in 2019, during the pro-democracy movement, and interviewed nine Hong Kong people. Some were normal people like us, who were valiant protesters; others were legislators and scholars. Back then, we wanted to paint a picture about these people and understand what made them take to the streets, what they were feeling when they protested and what made them desperately fight for power under any circumstances.

“None of us could foresee that the National Security Law would soon be imposed on Hong Kong. In less than one year, we knew that the lives of these nine people would have changed drastically. We strongly wanted to write a follow-up report about what happened to them. 

“I felt sorry that some of them chose not to be interviewed again for fear of what would happen. I also felt so thankful that some were brave enough to accept, and told us that they were continuing with their defiance and protests. 

“Others told us that they had started hiding their social media posts out of fear. We tried conveying what this must have felt like, and how the new law changed their lives.

“Journalism is the first rough draft of history. We hope we can do our best to show our readers the truth and real change that Hong Kong has been facing.” 

 


 

Documentary Video: Chinese

Paul Lee, Bao Choy, Sze-sze Cheng, Flora Yeung, Judy Chan and Yiu-ling Wong, Radio Television Hong Kong

RTHK’s investigation into the Yuen Long attack of July 2019, which saw an armed mob beat commuters and protesters inside a subway station, was praised by the judges for “chasing the smallest clues” and “interrogating the powerful without fear or favour.”

Freelance producer Bao Choy was convicted and fined HK$6,000 in April for making false statements while obtaining vehicle registration records during her research. RTHK had tried to withdraw its entries from the competition but HRPA organisers declined to cooperate. In the wake of her conviction, we spoke with Choy and her teammate Sze-sze Cheng about their investigation and reporting process.

Bao Choy: “A year after the attack, many of the victims still haven’t found justice and the assailants remain unpunished. This should not be accepted in a civilised city. We therefore decided to reopen the investigation and look at all the tiny details which could provide more information and the forces behind the attack.

“A team of four spent a few months re-watching all the online footage from the night, as well as CCTV footage. We had to mark every tiny clue, and use those clues for further investigation. We used a spreadsheet to share our discoveries, partnering in teams of two to approach the alleged assailants because of security concerns.”

Sze-sze Cheng: “The process was long, but very rewarding. The most memorable part was when we approached villagers and asked for their responses. It was dangerous, but it was part of our job and we had to do it.”

Choy: “It was extremely difficult to get people to talk to us about this particular incident. It seems those white clad-men involved were asked to remain silent. In some ways, their silence reflects a part of the truth.

“Being truthful and transparent are the core values of our work as journalists. Winning this award is recognition of our team and effort. It is proof that we will counter those who want to erase or rewrite history.” 

Cheng: “Our reporter Bao Choy was charged and convicted of false declaration. I think that’s the most cynical thing, and she did her best to fight press freedom. Our work is a part of history and serves as important documentation.”

 


 

WINNER – Photography (Single Image)

The Struggle
Alex Chan Tsz Yuk, CityDog.by
Hong Kong, 10 May 2020

Protestor arrested Hong Kong A protester signals “Five demands, not one less” while getting arrested in Mong Kok.

 

WINNER – People’s Choice Photo Award

Little Brother and Little Sister
Fung Hoi Kin, Ming Pao
Hong Kong, 6 September 2020

When police “kettled” a crowd of demonstrators in Hong Kong, two young childen – brother and sister – attempted to flee but were grabbed by heavily armed officers. In a futile attempt to protect her, the boy reached out to his sibling.

‘Little Brother and Little Sister’ won the People’s Choice Award with more than 21,000 online votes. The Correspondent spoke with one of the HRPA organisers, Mary Hui, about the winning shot. 

“The photo was taken at the height of the mass protests. As has been widely reported, the Hong Kong police increasingly adopted a tactic of ‘kettling’ protesters and other citizens who happened to be near an area of protest, making mass arrests by sweeping up large groups of people,” says Hui. 

“This image of two underage siblings dressed in shorts and a T-shirt being forcibly restrained and overpowered by fully geared-up riot police officers is very striking. The widely documented use of heavy force by the police, and the unaccountability of the officers, was and continues to be a major public grievance that has severely damaged trust in law enforcement, and more broadly, the government. 

“I imagine that many people who voted for this photo thought that the image captured and represented these complexities in a split second.” 

 

MERIT – Photography (Single Image)

A Mob out for Blood
Danish Siddiqui, Reuters
India,
24 February 2020

A group of men chanting pro-Hindu slogans, beat Mohammad Zubair, 37, who is Muslim, during protests sparked by a new citizenship law in New Delhi. Zubair was on his way home from a mosque when he came across a large Hindu crowd. “They saw I was alone, they saw my cap, beard, clothes and saw me as a Muslim,” Zubair said. “They just started attacking, shouting slogans. What kind of humanity is this?”

 

WINNER –  Photography Series

Citizenship Law Protests
Danish Siddiqui, Reuters, India

An injured man is rushed to a hospital after clashes erupted over a new citizenship law in New Delhi on 25 February 2020.

 

A man brandishes a gun during a protest outside the Jamia Millia Islamia university in New Delhi on 30 January  2020.

 

MERIT –  Photography Series

Pro-Democracy Protests in Thailand
Lillian Suwanrumpha, Mladen Antonov and Jack Taylor, AFP, Thailand

Anti-government protesters gather in Sanam Luang during a pro-democracy rally in Bangkok on 19 September 2020.

 

A protester portraying a victim of abuse at school grimaces during a ‘Bad Student’ rally in Bangkok on 21 November 2020.

 

MERIT –  Photography Series

Plight of the Poor in India’s Lockdown
Jewel Samad, Arun Sankar, Money Sharma, Bhuvan Bagga, Sajjad Hussain Indranil Mukherjee and Himanshu Sharma, AFP, India

Police detain stranded migrant workers in Surat during a nationwide coronavirus lockdown on 4 May 2020.

 

A policeman fills up bottles with water for migrant workers in Ajmer after the government eased a nationwide lockdown on 18 May 2020.

 


 

Rhea Mogul is a Hong Kong-based journalist interested in gender issues and minority rights. Her work has appeared in a number of publications including Forbes.com, Hong Kong Free Press and South China Morning Post.

Covering the Coup: A Myanmar Journalist Reports

Chronicling events on the ground in Yangon, Arakanese freelance journalist Kyaw Hsan Hlaing documents an increasingly perilous situation for journalists in the wake of the military coup.

Protesters demonstrate against the military coup in Yangon on 14 February 2021. Protesters demonstrate against the military coup in Yangon on 14 February 2021. (Photo: Sai Aung Main / AFP)

When my roommate woke me early on 1 February with the news that the Myanmar military had staged a coup, I knew that as a freelance journalist focused on human rights I could become a target.

I deactivated my Facebook account and requested the editor at an international news agency delete my byline from some sensitive articles. I then walked around my neighbourhood in Yangon to assess the situation. Everywhere I looked, I saw faces lined with fear and uncertainty.

The military had cut my phone connection, but I heard a rumour that one network was still accessible. I queued for two hours to buy a SIM card, but when I activated it, there was still no connection.

After the military, known as the Tatmadaw, arrested former State Counsellor Aung San Suu Kyi along with more than 40 party officials and declared a year-long state of emergency, everything has taken on a new urgency, including my work as a journalist.

I have been reporting around the clock as a freelance journalist for publications such as TIME, Al Jazeera, The Nation, The Globe and Mail, VICE News and Columbia Journalism Review in partnership with US-based freelance journalist, Emily Fishbein, who worked in Myanmar from 2015 to 2020. During the pandemic, we teamed up to write about armed conflict between the Arakan Army and Burmese military in my native Rakhine state, and we have been working together since.

A protester holds a sign denouncing Myanmar General Min Aung Hlaing. A protester holds a sign denouncing Myanmar General Min Aung Hlaing. (Photo: STR / AFP)

As hundreds of thousands demonstrate and workers strike across every sector, the situation continues to intensify. On the weekend of 13-14 March, at least 51 people were fatally shot, bringing the total number of people killed by soldiers and police since the coup up to at least 126. According to The New York Times, more than a fifth of those killed have been teenagers.

More than 2,100 people have been arrested as of 13 March, according to the Assistance Association for Political Prisoners, and many of those arrested were seized from their homes at night without a warrant. At least 37 journalists have also been taken into custody, of whom 15 have not yet been released; some were beaten upon arrest while others have been forced to sign statements that they will cease reporting.

Five prominent Yangon-based media groups have had their licenses revoked and been banned from publishing on any platform, while the military has raided several media outlets, seizing computers, printers and data servers. The military is arbitrarily shutting down the internet and people, including me, are afraid to make phone calls in case the calls could be intercepted.

Living under an authoritarian state is all too familiar in Myanmar, which was run by a military junta from 1962 to 2011. During those years, we were surrounded by informers, the government heavily censored media, and SIM cards were kept prohibitively expensive (upwards of US$7,000 in 1998 and around US$625 in 2011), effectively cutting off our access to news and information.

(click to enlarge)

In 2011, the military began a series of reforms, and in 2013, the price of SIM cards dropped hundredfold. I accessed the internet for the first time from my village in Rakhine, on the western coast, in 2014.

Myanmar held openly democratic elections in November 2015, bringing the National League for Democracy (NLD) to power. Nobel Peace Prize laureate Aung San Suu Kyi became the country’s de facto leader, and although the country was still under a 2008 military-drafted constitution allowing the civilian government and generals to share power, many expected that the NLD would counter the military’s influence and champion democracy and human rights.

Aung San Suu Kyi dashed expectations when she defended the military against charges of genocide for its treatment of the Rohingya at the International Court of Justice in 2019. Other ethnic groups in Myanmar, including my own Arakanese community (also called ethnic Rakhine), have also been bitterly disappointed by Aung San Suu Kyi’s failure to condemn human rights abuses that the Tatmadaw allegedly committed, including war crimes and crimes against humanity.

Instead, her government backed the Tatmadaw’s violent campaigns, blocked humanitarian access and, in parts of my home state and the neighbouring Chin state, imposed the world’s longest internet shutdown. Since 21 June 2019, government restrictions on the internet left more than 1 million people without effective access for 19 months.

The NLD government also cracked down on press freedom, especially in Rakhine, where it blocked independent media access to conflict-affected areas beginning in 2016, with the exception of pre-arranged reporting tours in which journalists were accompanied by government minders.

During the first four years of NLD’s term (2015-2018), 67 lawsuits were filed against journalists and media personnel. Of these, 31 were filed by the government; 11 by the military; and the rest by religious institutions, tycoons, employers, political parties, armed groups and others, according to a report in May 2020 by Yangon-based freedom of expression organisation Athan.

Kyaw Hsan Hlaing reports from Yangon. Kyaw Hsan Hlaing reports from Yangon. (Photo: Supplied)

More than three dozen journalists were charged with defamation, while others were charged with supporting an unlawful association or alleged terrorist group when they reported on conflict between the Tatmadaw and ethnic armed organisations or interviewed their spokespersons.

In 2018, the government imprisoned Reuters journalists Wa Lone and Kyaw Soe Oo for possessing classified information which police had planted on them, while they were reporting on the massacre of 10 Rohingya in Rakhine. They spent more than 500 days behind bars before being released in May 2019 under a presidential amnesty.

While the NLD severely curtailed media freedoms, sinking back under military rule is far worse. Almost immediately, journalism became significantly more challenging and dangerous, and the obstacles and risks are increasing by the day.

On 27 February, I went out to observe the protests. After being tear-gassed, I ran away from authorities only to come face to face with a soldier. He pointed a gun at my friend and me, and said: “Back up, I don’t want to shoot you.” I backed up and immediately left the area.

Mapping Myanmar (click to enlarge)

What’s more, the social media landscape has changed dramatically. Facebook, which serves as the main source of news, information and communications in Myanmar, has long been used as a vehicle for hate speech and disinformation targeting ethnic minorities. After the military banned the platform on 4 February, users migrated to Twitter en masse. Two days later, the military banned Twitter as well, but users have continued to access both platforms using VPNs.

Since the coup, my Twitter followers jumped from around 400 to nearly 10,000 as of 14 March. I have not received any serious threats online, but I worry that malicious activity will increase; I have already seen a spike in trolling and disinformation on the platform.

Intermittent internet shutdowns have posed another major problem. While the hazards of social media are many, the lack of online access is even more dangerous. Unable to check reliable news sites or trusted sources to verify information, I have been calling my contact at a fact-checking civil society organisation for assistance. But now she sometimes replies that the group is unable to confidently make an assessment.

With arrests increasing, I have taken extensive precautions to protect myself. On the day of the coup,I wrote down important phone numbers in my notebook, using nicknames in case police confiscated it. Next, I deleted all contacts, audio files and messages from my phone. I began using VPNs to access the internet, and when I use phone data, I switch between four SIM cards to separate my personal communications, browsing history, and reporting work – a strategy I had also used when reporting on armed conflict in Rakhine.

It is now much harder to collect information as I do not trust anyone. When I go outside, I am constantly alert and carefully assessing my surroundings. Informers could be anywhere, and I often feel as though people are watching me, especially when I carry my camera. I don’t talk openly with taxi drivers, and I am guarded even with my closest friends and family. I avoid talking deeply about my feelings and personal information as well, because people could take advantage of my vulnerabilities.

I see journalism as a tool to solve problems, and I am particularly motivated to promote human rights and social justice. I aim for in-depth coverage which prioritises the inclusion of diverse voices and especially those who are vulnerable and marginalised, such as displaced people, ethnic minorities and those living in remote areas.

Covering under-reported stories during an emergency, I feel an extra sense of responsibility to document what is happening accurately, informatively and effectively. Despite the risks and pressures, I feel strongly motivated to persevere.

The most important thing is to share what is happening in Myanmar with the world. My country has already gone to the dark side, and if we don’t do anything, we may become trapped under military control for a long time. We need to end this situation and find our way to the light. Each of us has our own role to play. For me, that role is journalism.

As told to Emily Fishbein, Kyaw Hsan Hlaing’s reporting partner, on 14 February 2021. Last updated on 14 March 2021, hours after the military issued a directive to telecoms operators to shut down the internet indefinitely in the country.


Kyaw Hsan Hlaing is an Arakanese student, researcher, and freelance journalist from Myanmar’s Rakhine state who focuses on peace, human rights; and social justice. He works to share on-the-ground situations of diverse people, especially marginalised and conflict-affected minorities, with the international community.

Emily Fishbein is an independent freelance journalist who worked in Myanmar from 2015 to 2020 and plans to return when she is able. She seeks to share diverse voices and perspectives, especially highlighting underreported stories. Prior to writing, she worked with refugees and displaced persons in Myanmar and the United States.

 

Covering the Coup: A Myanmar Journalist Reports

Chronicling events on the ground in Yangon, Arakanese freelance journalist Kyaw Hsan Hlaing documents an increasingly perilous situation for journalists in the wake of the military coup.

Protesters demonstrate against the military coup in Yangon on 14 February 2021. Protesters demonstrate against the military coup in Yangon on 14 February 2021. (Photo: Sai Aung Main / AFP)

When my roommate woke me early on 1 February with the news that the Myanmar military had staged a coup, I knew that as a freelance journalist focused on human rights I could become a target.

I deactivated my Facebook account and requested the editor at an international news agency delete my byline from some sensitive articles. I then walked around my neighbourhood in Yangon to assess the situation. Everywhere I looked, I saw faces lined with fear and uncertainty. 

The military had cut my phone connection, but I heard a rumour that one network was still accessible. I queued for two hours to buy a SIM card, but when I activated it, there was still no connection.

After the military, known as the Tatmadaw, arrested former State Counsellor Aung San Suu Kyi along with more than 40 party officials and declared a year-long state of emergency, everything has taken on a new urgency, including my work as a journalist.

I have been reporting around the clock as a freelance journalist for publications such as TIME, Al Jazeera, The Nation, The Globe and Mail, VICE News and Columbia Journalism Review in partnership with US-based freelance journalist, Emily Fishbein, who worked in Myanmar from 2015 to 2020. During the pandemic, we teamed up to write about armed conflict between the Arakan Army and Burmese military in my native Rakhine state, and we have been working together since. 

A protester holds a sign denouncing Myanmar General Min Aung Hlaing. A protester holds a sign denouncing Myanmar General Min Aung Hlaing. (Photo: STR / AFP)

As hundreds of thousands demonstrate and workers strike across every sector, the situation continues to intensify. On the weekend of 13-14 March, at least 51 people were fatally shot, bringing the total number of people killed by soldiers and police since the coup up to at least 126. According to The New York Times, more than a fifth of those killed have been teenagers. 

More than 2,100 people have been arrested as of 13 March, according to the Assistance Association for Political Prisoners, and many of those arrested were seized from their homes at night without a warrant. At least 37 journalists have also been taken into custody, of whom 15 have not yet been released; some were beaten upon arrest while others have been forced to sign statements that they will cease reporting.

Five prominent Yangon-based media groups have had their licenses revoked and been banned from publishing on any platform, while the military has raided several media outlets, seizing computers, printers and data servers. The military is arbitrarily shutting down the internet and people, including me, are afraid to make phone calls in case the calls could be intercepted. 

Living under an authoritarian state is all too familiar in Myanmar, which was run by a military junta from 1962 to 2011. During those years, we were surrounded by informers, the government heavily censored media, and SIM cards were kept prohibitively expensive (upwards of US$7,000 in 1998 and around US$625 in 2011), effectively cutting off our access to news and information.

(click to enlarge)

In 2011, the military began a series of reforms, and in 2013, the price of SIM cards dropped hundredfold. I accessed the internet for the first time from my village in Rakhine, on the western coast, in 2014.

Myanmar held openly democratic elections in November 2015, bringing the National League for Democracy (NLD) to power. Nobel Peace Prize laureate Aung San Suu Kyi became the country’s de facto leader, and although the country was still under a 2008 military-drafted constitution allowing the civilian government and generals to share power, many expected that the NLD would counter the military’s influence and champion democracy and human rights.

Aung San Suu Kyi dashed expectations when she defended the military against charges of genocide for its treatment of the Rohingya at the International Court of Justice in 2019. Other ethnic groups in Myanmar, including my own Arakanese community (also called ethnic Rakhine), have also been bitterly disappointed by Aung San Suu Kyi’s failure to condemn human rights abuses that the Tatmadaw allegedly committed, including war crimes and crimes against humanity. 

Instead, her government backed the Tatmadaw’s violent campaigns, blocked humanitarian access and, in parts of my home state and the neighbouring Chin state, imposed the world’s longest internet shutdown. Since 21 June 2019, government restrictions on the internet left more than 1 million people without effective access for 19 months.

The NLD government also cracked down on press freedom, especially in Rakhine, where it blocked independent media access to conflict-affected areas beginning in 2016, with the exception of pre-arranged reporting tours in which journalists were accompanied by government minders.

During the first four years of NLD’s term (2015-2018), 67 lawsuits were filed against journalists and media personnel. Of these, 31 were filed by the government; 11 by the military; and the rest by religious institutions, tycoons, employers, political parties, armed groups and others, according to a report in May 2020 by Yangon-based freedom of expression organisation Athan. 

Kyaw Hsan Hlaing reports from Yangon. Kyaw Hsan Hlaing reports from Yangon. (Photo: Supplied)

More than three dozen journalists were charged with defamation, while others were charged with supporting an unlawful association or alleged terrorist group when they reported on conflict between the Tatmadaw and ethnic armed organisations or interviewed their spokespersons. 

In 2018, the government imprisoned Reuters journalists Wa Lone and Kyaw Soe Oo for possessing classified information which police had planted on them, while they were reporting on the massacre of 10 Rohingya in Rakhine. They spent more than 500 days behind bars before being released in May 2019 under a presidential amnesty.

While the NLD severely curtailed media freedoms, sinking back under military rule is far worse. Almost immediately, journalism became significantly more challenging and dangerous, and the obstacles and risks are increasing by the day. 

On 27 February, I went out to observe the protests. After being tear-gassed, I ran away from authorities only to come face to face with a soldier. He pointed a gun at my friend and me, and said: “Back up, I don’t want to shoot you.” I backed up and immediately left the area.

Mapping Myanmar (click to enlarge)

What’s more, the social media landscape has changed dramatically. Facebook, which serves as the main source of news, information and communications in Myanmar, has long been used as a vehicle for hate speech and disinformation targeting ethnic minorities. After the military banned the platform on 4 February, users migrated to Twitter en masse. Two days later, the military banned Twitter as well, but users have continued to access both platforms using VPNs.

Since the coup, my Twitter followers jumped from around 400 to nearly 10,000 as of 14 March. I have not received any serious threats online, but I worry that malicious activity will increase; I have already seen a spike in trolling and disinformation on the platform.

Intermittent internet shutdowns have posed another major problem. While the hazards of social media are many, the lack of online access is even more dangerous. Unable to check reliable news sites or trusted sources to verify information, I have been calling my contact at a fact-checking civil society organisation for assistance. But now she sometimes replies that the group is unable to confidently make an assessment.

With arrests increasing, I have taken extensive precautions to protect myself. On the day of the coup,I wrote down important phone numbers in my notebook, using nicknames in case police confiscated it. Next, I deleted all contacts, audio files and messages from my phone. I began using VPNs to access the internet, and when I use phone data, I switch between four SIM cards to separate my personal communications, browsing history, and reporting work – a strategy I had also used when reporting on armed conflict in Rakhine.

It is now much harder to collect information as I do not trust anyone. When I go outside, I am constantly alert and carefully assessing my surroundings. Informers could be anywhere, and I often feel as though people are watching me, especially when I carry my camera. I don’t talk openly with taxi drivers, and I am guarded even with my closest friends and family. I avoid talking deeply about my feelings and personal information as well, because people could take advantage of my vulnerabilities.

I see journalism as a tool to solve problems, and I am particularly motivated to promote human rights and social justice. I aim for in-depth coverage which prioritises the inclusion of diverse voices and especially those who are vulnerable and marginalised, such as displaced people, ethnic minorities and those living in remote areas. 

Covering under-reported stories during an emergency, I feel an extra sense of responsibility to document what is happening accurately, informatively and effectively. Despite the risks and pressures, I feel strongly motivated to persevere. 

The most important thing is to share what is happening in Myanmar with the world. My country has already gone to the dark side, and if we don’t do anything, we may become trapped under military control for a long time. We need to end this situation and find our way to the light. Each of us has our own role to play. For me, that role is journalism.

As told to Emily Fishbein, Kyaw Hsan Hlaing’s reporting partner, on 14 February 2021. Last updated on 14 March 2021, hours after the military issued a directive to telecoms operators to shut down the internet indefinitely in the country.


Kyaw Hsan Hlaing is an Arakanese student, researcher, and freelance journalist from Myanmar’s Rakhine state who focuses on peace, human rights; and social justice. He works to share on-the-ground situations of diverse people, especially marginalised and conflict-affected minorities, with the international community.

 

Emily Fishbein is an independent freelance journalist who worked in Myanmar from 2015 to 2020 and plans to return when she is able. She seeks to share diverse voices and perspectives, especially highlighting underreported stories. Prior to writing, she worked with refugees and displaced persons in Myanmar and the United States.

 

Hong Kong’s National Security Law: Implications for Journalists

As soon as the government enacted the national security law on 30 June, the rules changed for Hong Kong journalists. Kate Springer discusses the potential implications with legal and journalism experts. 

Hong Kong Chief Executive Carrie Lam discusses the national security law at a press conference on 7 July, 2020. PHOTO: ISAAC LAWRENCE / AFP Hong Kong Chief Executive Carrie Lam discusses the national security law at a press conference on 7 July, 2020. PHOTO: ISAAC LAWRENCE / AFP

When the Chinese Standing Committee of the National People’s Congress enacted the Hong Kong national security law on 30 June, the city changed overnight. The far-reaching law criminalises “terrorist activities”, “secession”, “subversion”, “collusion” with foreign entities and inciting “hatred among Hong Kong residents” towards the local or central government – not just in Hong Kong, but anywhere in the world. The law, however, does not define these crimes, leaving room for interpretation by authorities and the courts. 

Despite assurances in Article 4 that “freedoms of speech, of the press, of publication” will be safeguarded, many journalists and news agencies remain concerned. There is good reason to worry: For starters, the law states that the government will take greater measures to regulate and manage the media, as well as “promote national security education” in the media. 

In addition, the government could require journalists to relinquish sensitive material, if it relates to an investigation under the new law. It remains unclear if journalists can interview pro-democracy voices, criticise the law or print offending slogans. On 7 July, the FCC hosted a panel with veteran journalists and legal experts to hear their thoughts on the national security law (NSL). 

From the high-profile arrest of Jimmy Lai to mass disqualification of pro-democracy lawmakers and unexplained delays in granting journalist visas, a lot has changed since then. In mid-August, we invited the panelists to revisit the conversation at the FCC. 

Pro-democracy media mogul Jimmy Lai (centre), 72, in police custody on 10 August, 2020. PHOTO: VERNON YUEN / AFP Pro-democracy media mogul Jimmy Lai (centre), 72, in police custody on 10 August, 2020. PHOTO: VERNON YUEN / AFP

Before we kick this off, can you introduce yourselves? 

Sharron Fast: I’m a lecturer in media law and the deputy director of the Master of Journalism programme at the Journalism and Media Studies Centre (JMSC) at The University of Hong Kong (HKU). I also teach in the Faculty of Law at HKU. 

Keith Richburg: I’m the director of the JMSC, HKU’s school of journalism. I’m also a longtime FCC member and a board member. 

Antony Dapiran: I’m a writer and lawyer. I’ve also written two books on Hong Kong’s protest movements, including City on Fire, about last year’s events. 

What does the NSL say about journalism? 

SF: If we look at Articles 9 and 10, the law says the Hong Kong government has a duty to ensure that mechanisms are put in place to promote the national security law through the media. That is sounding dangerously like propaganda. It doesn’t mean a free press – it means that the government will ensure that the media gets the coverage ‘right’. 

AD: I’d also highlight Article 54, which has caused grave concern. The article says the government will ‘strengthen the management’ of foreign media, international organisations and NGOs. There’s a great deal of uncertainty over what that will mean. But it is certainly ominous. 

How are you feeling about the law at the moment? 

KR: Some [decisions] have given me more optimism. For example, the law didn’t provide any presumption of bail, but Jimmy Lai was released on bail. Others have made me more pessimistic. Sending about 200 police officers into the Apple Daily newsroom [on 10 August] was a shocking trampling on press freedom. I’ve covered the Middle East and authoritarian governments in Africa, and I don’t recall seeing police search a critical newsroom like that. 

AD: And then lying about it after the fact. They claimed not to have searched news materials when there’s footage of police rifling through journalists’ desks. That’s troubling. 

KR: When the FCC put out a statement criticising the raid at Apple Daily and the arrest of Jimmy Lai, they accused us of ‘smearing’ the national security law. They’re implying that even being critical of the law could itself be a violation. That tramples on free speech. I may have to obey the law, but it is still my right to criticise it. 

Antony Dapiran (left) and Keith Richburg (right) discuss the implications of the national security law at the FCC on 15 August, 2020. PHOTO: BEN MARANS Antony Dapiran (left) and Keith Richburg (right) discuss the implications of the national security law at the FCC on 15 August, 2020. PHOTO: BEN MARANS

August 10 was a sad day for the Hong Kong press. What stood out to you? 

SF: We had many sharp shocks that Monday. Around 7 a.m., Jimmy Lai is being arrested. By 10 a.m., the police are entering Next Digital [the publisher of Apple Daily]. Then quietly, news breaks about the immigration situation – people start noticing changes to foreign visa applications. Then we hear about changes to directorships of broadcast news. It was just layer after layer. These weren’t coincidences – every single thing that happened that day is part of creating an atmosphere of fear. 

KR: Let’s not forget, the week before, it seemed like politicians had their day. The government disqualified [a dozen] politicians and cancelled the elections entirely. 

SF: We have everyone from politicians to video journalists to media executives being targeted… If I look at someone like [freelance journalist and activist] Wilson Li versus [media mogul] Jimmy Lai, it’s clear that this law is an ‘all creatures great and small’ kind of instrument.

AD: It has a calculated chilling effect. I think you’re right – the point they want to make is that anyone is at risk.

KR: I’m speculating a little bit here, but I don’t think their intention is to conduct mass arrests in Hong Kong. With these targeted arrests, they can scare a lot more people. 

You know, the old Chinese saying, sha ji xia hou (殺雞儆猴), which means, ‘You kill the chicken to scare the monkey’. That raid on Apple Daily, disqualifying candidates and picking up young students… that’s just killing a few chickens. But all of us monkeys are thinking, ‘Wow, I don’t want to be like that chicken. Maybe I better fall in line.’ 

How could the law pose problems for journalists? 

KR: Personally, I write a lot of op-eds these days. I think it’s still okay to address what’s happening here and offer my interpretations, but I am going to be more cautious about calling on world powers to do anything. That could be interpreted as ‘inciting foreign intervention’. 

SF: Anything is possible with this law. Let’s talk about Article 20 on secession, which includes participation as part of the offence. But what is participating in secession? It’s undefined, unclear. Does this include interviewing [a pro-democracy or pro-independence activist]? Are you an accessory if you give them a platform? 

KR: We have already seen an increase in self-censorship across some media outlets. And here at the FCC, we do a lot of events and Zoom panels. We have a lot of debates about who to have on, as we have gotten in trouble in the past. 

SF: Yes, and the law is unclear [about what it means to advocate secession]. Normally, under Common Law, you would need to prove intent. But the national security law is crafted to be very purposive, meaning that the purpose of the accused individual is presumed. For example, a person will be assumed to have the intention to advocate secession by displaying a flag imprinted with the phrase ‘HK Independence’. 

What if a reporter obtains documents that could be considered ‘state secrets’? 

KR: Let’s hypothesise: A police officer is upset about police brutality and has some internal documents to prove that the department buried an investigation. The whistleblower passes the documents to a reporter who writes a story. Now, I would imagine the top brass might accuse that reporter of possessing ‘national security documents’ and ‘fomenting unlawful hatred’. What liability would that journalist have? 

SF: I think direct [liability]. You might have to publish it overseas. There are no sunshine laws [freedom of information laws in the US that require federal bodies to disclose information]. And, whereas in the US, you can go after the leaker but not the reporter, that won’t stand here. 

AD: There would also be pressure on the media to reveal the identity of the leaker. Just saying, ‘I can’t reveal my sources’ is going to be a difficult argument. 

Sharron Fast unpacks the law’s vague language at the FCC. PHOTO: BEN MARANS Sharron Fast unpacks the law’s vague language at the FCC. PHOTO: BEN MARANS

How might the government punish ‘rogue’ media? 

KR: I worked in mainland China as a correspondent for The Washington Post [from 2009 to 2013]. They had this idea of collective punishment. For example, I was invited on a government-sponsored trip to Tibet. At the last minute, they said there was no space for me because The Post had written an editorial criticising what was happening in Xinjiang. 

Even though I had nothing to do with it, they said: ‘Yes, but you are The Washington Post’s person in China. So you are responsible.’ So what happens if Nathan Law or Jimmy Lai writes an op-ed that appears in The New York Times or The Washington Post in the US? Since they can’t get to the reporter overseas, would they punish the bureaus here? All we have to go on is how they do it in China. 

AD: True, but even though it is hard to report in China, we still see excellent journalism coming out of the country. 

KR: Absolutely. China is one of the most restrictive places for journalists in the world. It ranks 177 out of 180 countries, according to Reporters Without Borders. But there’s good journalism being done if you look at Caixin, Southern Weekend, Sixth Tone, The New York Times’ Xinjiang papers… 

AD: In Hong Kong, journalists will need to be more careful. They will need to learn from how journalists operate in other countries, like in Thailand, where you can’t criticise the military or the monarchy. 

KR: Even in Myanmar, there’s good reporting. It takes brave journalists, brave editors, brave websites that are still going to print this stuff. At the same time, we need to pay attention and start to learn where the red lines are – and know that they will always be shifting.

Could entrapment become more common? 

SF: The lengths to which authorities will go to in order to ensnare journalists are still unknown. Right now, everyone’s thinking about legal advice, encryption, using Signal – doing everything possible to keep the forensics clean. 

KR: Journalists will figure it out. They have to learn how to navigate the new rules, protect their sources, data and notebooks. We can’t just pretend things are the way they were before. You may have to use burner cell phones, VPNs, remember your interviews instead of taking notes, and assume you’re being surveilled. 

AD: That is a good point. The law has a whole raft of mechanisms that can compel people to provide documents and answer questions. So the way journalists record and safeguard their data is going to be important. 

Do you think press freedom is dead in Hong Kong? 

KR: Press freedom is dead, in terms of being protected by law. That said, I believe press freedom will survive because of the bravery of journalists, who get out there and report. 

SF: There is definitely still a pulse. We have a great new cohort at HKU this year. Our students are extremely interested in reporting here; this attempt to extinguish press freedom and free expression is the biggest story in the world right now. It is the story of their generation. 

AD: And certainly, I was heartened by the public’s reaction to Apple Daily and all the outpouring of support they’ve seen since the arrests and newsroom raid. That shows how important press freedom is to the people of Hong Kong. 

Read the law in full here.

We measure site performance with cookies to improve performance.